by David Cartwright
ย
ย ย ย ย ย ย ย ย Itโs funny what we remember and what we forget. Some things stick with us for a lifetime. Others refuse to come to light. One insight that has stayed with me now for fifty years is a comment one of my professors made while I was in divinity school. The class was discussing various views of the doctrine of the Eucharist. Speaking of Reformation viewpoints, the professor said, โWhat you have to realize is that Lutherโs question was, โWhat does the text say?โ Calvinโs question was, โWhat does the text mean?โ That is the basis of their disagreement on Jesusโ words, โThis is my body.โ Luther came away from the text with a doctrine of the ubiquitous presence of Christ in the elements, while Calvin believed in a memorial interpretation. After all, as Calvin put it, Christโs body cannot be in the elements since Jesus ascended into Heaven. Needless to say, the discussion has continued to this day, with a sordid history of in-hospitality on both sides of the divide. What did Jesus mean when he said, โThis is my body.โ?
Well, thatโs not the only scriptural saying of Jesus we could reflect on. Thereโs an interesting place in the Gospel of Luke (Chapter 22) that suggests that some of Jesusโ disciples were carrying weapons. Earlier in Chapter 10, Jesus had explicitly told his disciples to go out with no bag, no purse, no sandals. Now he tells them to sell their cloak and buy a sword. Picking up on this, the disciples say โLook, Lord, here are two swords,โ most likely the ever-present near-Eastern dagger. Jesus replies, โIt is enough.โ What on earth could he mean? Does he mean that two swords are enough? Thatโs all they need. Some commentators say no. These commentators say that this is not what Jesus meant at all. Others take a slightly different tack. They say that when Jesus saw that even his disciples were carrying swords, his heart was broken. They hadnโt gotten his message of non-violence. Still others say that Jesus is simply acknowledging that there is no way around violence in this world. โLet them have their way.โ And sadly, even his disciples will be a part of it.
Obviously, the interpretation of this passage continues to cause us to reflect on the question, โWhat did Jesus mean?โ The Two Sword passage has been used by some to justify going to war and by others to justify having nothing to do with war. Personally, I can see how these scriptures might apply both to situations of war and of non-violence. That is why I personally cannot conclude that Jesus is a pacifist, as many believe; nor do I think heโs an insurrectionist, as at least one is saying these days. Taken together with other things Jesus had to say, these scriptures help me see what the other side is talking about. Specifically, Luke 10 and Luke 22 taken together at least force us to ask the right questions, if not ultimately arriving at the answers weโre looking for. For instance, what are we to make of the use of drones in air strikes? What would Jesus think of this? As a Christian, all I can say is that finally itโs up to us to make the hard decision based on what we think Jesus means. That is the one thing I am confident that Jesus asks of us.
Next time: What did Jesus say?







